| American Hotel, The |
| 49 Main St. (bet. Bay & Washington Sts.) |
631-725-3535
www.theamericanhotel.com |
|
| Night Decor |
Night Service |
Night Appeal |
| 23 |
23 |
24 |
|
| Voted Most Popular and tops for Decor among Hamptons nightspots, this Sag Harbor "classic" draws a "cool, mature" crowd with its "beautiful, historic" setting in the American Hotel (built in 1846), "stellar" 80-page-plus wine list and prime seating for mixing with "beautful people", whether on the porch, in the "Parisian"-feeling dining rooms or by the "gorgeous mahogany bar" and fireplace; a few find it a bit "stuffy" (bring "your parents") and its not "for the weak of wallet", but most are "never disappointed" by this "old local favorite." |
|
|
| 21 Water |
| 21 W. Water St. (Long Island Ave.) |
631-725-4925
www.twentyonewater.com |
|
| Night Decor |
Night Service |
Night Appeal |
| 20 |
18 |
22 |
|
| Disembark from your "posh yacht at the marina" and step into this "loud, young and loud!" Sag Harbor club, complete with an Italian restaurant, blue-canopied patio and separate DJ rooms for rock/hip-hop and Euro/house music; it offers "trendy drinks" and a scene to match, but a few warn that "the level of pretentiousness is skyrocketing." |
|
|
| JLX Bistro |
| 16 Main St. (bet. Long Island Ave. & Meadow St.) |
631-725-9100
www.jlxbistro.com |
|
| Night Decor |
Night Service |
Night Appeal |
| 22 |
19 |
22 |
|
| "After a long day on your boat", this Sag Harbor sibling of JL East and NYCs Jean-Luc offers an "elegant bistro atmosphere" for dinner and drinks; assets include a patio and "beautiful bar" with a "great vibe", plus views of Main Street, Long Wharf and the "old windmill", but some report servers with "snippy attitudes." |
|
|
| Sen |
| 23 Main St. (bet. Bay & Madison Sts.) |
631-725-1774
www.senrestaurant.com |
|
| Night Decor |
Night Service |
Night Appeal |
| 18 |
18 |
19 |
|
| Space is at a premium inside this top-tier Japanese restaurant in Sag Harbor, and the tucked-away corner lounge is no exception; only three silver stools stand in front of the black granite-topped bar, but the young and the fabulous still squeeze into the chic little room for specialty cocktails like litchi martinis and sake cosmos. |
|
|
| Cigar Bar |
| 2 Main St. (Nassau St.) |
631-725-2575
www.hamptonscigarbar.com |
|
| Night Decor |
Night Service |
Night Appeal |
| 15 |
18 |
17 |
|
| Sag Harbors older set goes for the stogies, and whippersnappers for cigs, at "the last legal place to smoke" in Suffolk County – an "intimate", "old-school" room accented with red velvet and a granite-topped bar; the "great martinis" and cigars from a "walk-in humidor" attract "extremely diverse" types, including a "late-night waiter/waitress" clientele, but space-conscious sorts note that it can get "overcrowded", and those expecting a mature scene may find it "way young." |
|
|
