Theresa Andrew

6 Listings
Theresa Andrew, a top realtor in The Hamptons for Corcoran, a real estate firm in Shelter Island.
  • Active Listings6
  • Press mentions9
  • Awards4

About Me

About Theresa Andrew

Highly involved and well known in her Shelter Island community, Theresa Andrew has strong roots to Shelter Island beginning with her grandparents. Her grandmother came to Shelter Island as a companion to the Lady of Sylvester Manor back in the late 1800’s. Her mother was born and raised on Shelter Island and her father born and raised in Riverhead. Her parents bought a home in Dering Harbor and when her father retired, he brought his family back to Shelter Island to live full time in their home in Dering Harbor. Before moving back, Theresa lived all over the world including being born in Taiwan, China; she is considered “an army brat.” She attended Shelter Island High School and went on to college at St. Michael’s College in Winooski/Burlington, Vermont. Coming home to Shelter Island, made her realize that this is where she wanted to raise her family. In 1996, Theresa’s family moved to Shelter Island to help with her aging parents.


  • 16 Years in Real Estate
  • 30 Years in Fundraising


  • St. Michael's College Class of 1978


  • Baking
  • Animal Lover
  • Cooking
  • Road Trips

Listings from Theresa Andrew

Sq Ft
Property Type

How should Theresa connect with you?

Additional Info


  • 2013Multi-Million Dollar Club
  • 2012#3 Producer - Shelter Island
  • 2012Multi-Million Dollar Club
  • 2001Most Valuable Fundraiser in State of New Jersey

Press Mentions

  • The New York Times On the Market on the North Fork and Shelter IslandRead more
  • Famed hotel manager selling Shelter Island sanctuaryRead more