Try using Chrome or Safari for an even better experience.

54 North Cartwright Road

Turn of the Century Farmhouse
cape | for Sale
WEB ID: 861273
  • Annual Tax: $3,489.00
  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1385 APPROX. SQFT
  • 0.47 ACREAGE
  • BUILT 1900

The Details

About 54 North Cartwright Road

Historic c.1900 Farmhouse renovated in 2001 retains original charming ambiance with modern conveniences. Located near Coecles Harbor Marina, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home has a covered front porch, living room with stone hearth and wood stove, master suite on the main level, and a large sunny open kitchen and dining area with doors to a back deck, patio and cedar hot tub. The second floor has 2 b...

key features
  • Garage
  • Hot tub/spa
  • Lot with trees
  • Studio

Interested? Let’s talk.

How should we connect with you?

Get to know Shelter Island

Shelter Island is an exclusive place made more so by its singularly notable position: Located between the North Fork and South Fork of Long Island, the beloved land mass looks out on Shelter Island Sound on its north, west, and south sides. Gardiners Bay (which spills into the Atlantic Ocean) laps at its eastern shore. The 27-square-mile island, which can be accessed by ferry in less than 10 minutes from both the North Fork and the South Fork, is marshy — a heaven for bird-watchers — and is noted for beautiful light and turquoise waters. It is also rich in history, from its earliest days as part of the Plymouth Company land grant in 1620. Today, Shelter Island is a premier destination for idyllic summering, as its irregular coastline translates into several natural harbors, bays, and wetlands that some of the most impressive properties have commandeered.

Shelter Island Neighborhood Guide
powered by GreatSchools

Calculate Monthly Costs

Mortgage Calculator

Mortgage Calculator

Not sure if this fits your budget? There might be tax savings, so talk to an agent for details.

  • 30 Years Fixed
  • 20 Years Fixed
  • 15 Years Fixed
  • 7 Years Fixed
  • 5 Years Fixed
  • Principal & Interest$3,036.36
  • Property Taxes$290.75
  • Maintenance / Common Charges0