Message goes here

19 Montclair Avenue

Storybook Waterfront Shelter Island Cottage With Dock Shelter Island
$2,000,000

This home has been sold

We have 2 similar homes for sale.
See Results

  • Cape
    4 Bedrooms   2 Bathrooms

Essentials

  • Price$2,000,000
  • StyleCape
  • Bedrooms4
  • Bathrooms2
  • Stories2
  • Approx. Sq. Ft.2,053
  • Acreage.56
  • Year Built1936

Key Features

  • Bayfront
  • Central air
  • Cul-de-sac location
  • Detached garage
  • Exercise room
  • Great room
  • Loft
  • Media room
  • Office
  • Outdoor shower
  • Cable/satellite

    Enjoy unrivaled sunrise and sunset views from this spectacular Shelter Island waterfront compound. An absolutely charming and unique property with waterfront on West Neck Harbor and waterviews of West Neck Creek. Beautiful and quiet Shelter Island is located conveniently to the newly discovered wine country the new Napa Valley and to all the Hamptons have to offer. Enclosed by clematis-covered white picket fence and completely renovated with every modern convenience, this 4-bedroom cottage has a spa/gym building, additional accessory building, outdoor shower, and a beautifully landscaped bluestone patio with stone firepit and millstone fountain. The first floor of the house has a spacious open layout including a living room with fireplace, dining and sitting rooms, chef's kitchen with stainless appliances, a bright and airy harborside sunroom, open creekside porch with swing plus 3 bedrooms and a full bath. The second floor living room with cathedral ceiling and skylight has a free-standing woodburning stove, large flat screen TV with surround sound, house media control center, wet bar and 2 spacious decks--each overlooking either harbor or creek. The master suite, with cathedral ceiling has a spa-bath with Jacuzzi perfectly situated for relaxing and watching the sailboats go by, huge walk-in shower and poured concrete floors. These Shelter Island grounds have old growth and specimen trees, lavender beds, a grand wisteria vine and many other flowering plants. The dock allows swimming, boating and fishing and there's a deep water mooring too! Permit is pending for inground pool.

    Bayfront, Central air, Cul-de-sac location, Detached garage, Exercise room, Great room, Loft, Media room, Office, Outdoor shower, Cable/satellite
    All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.

    Agents  Ask us a question

    Cee Scott Brown
    Cee Scott Brown Licensed Associate RE Broker m (516) 383-2011 p (631) 899-0119 ceebrown@corcoran.com Email Me See my 16 other sale listings
    Jack Pearson
    Jack Pearson Licensed Associate RE Broker p (631) 899-0307 m (516) 457-7111 jpearson@corcoran.com Email Me See my 15 other sale listings
    Peter McCracken
    Peter McCracken Licensed Associate RE Broker p (631) 749-2526 m (631) 774-0107 pmccracken@corcoran.com Email Me See my 6 other sale listings
    Corcoran

    Shelter Island

    Shelter Island

    Nestled between the North and South Forks, surrounded by calm waters, and accessible only by ferry, Shelter Island looks like a set piece from a golden age come to life.

    The Heights, a fantasia of Victoriana, is just up from the North Ferry dock. The homes of Shelter Island, however, express many styles -- from Southern colonials to Norman Jaffe modern and antique cottages.

    Explore Shelter Island

    What's In The Area

    Driving Walking

    Shelter Island

    Back To All Categories
    A
    • Restaurants (10)
    • Art and Museums (3)
    • Banks (2)
    • Beverages (2)
    • Boating (4)
    • Clothing and Accessories (2)
    • Grocery Stores and Markets (8)
    • Health Clubs and Spas (2)
    • Home and Garden (4)
    • Laundries - Cleaners (1)
    • Pharmacies (1)
    • Pet Services (1)
    • Public Schools (1)
    • Retail Shops and Markets (4)
    • Spas - Beauty (2)
    • Water Activities (1)
    • Grocery Stores and Markets (8)
    • Art and Museums (3)
    • Banks (2)
    • Beverages (2)
    • Boating (4)
    • Clothing and Accessories (2)
    • Health Clubs and Spas (2)
    • Home and Garden (4)
    • Laundries - Cleaners (1)
    • Pharmacies (1)
    • Restaurants (10)
    • Pet Services (1)
    • Public Schools (1)
    • Retail Shops and Markets (4)
    • Spas - Beauty (2)
    • Water Activities (1)
    • Health Clubs and Spas (2)
    • Art and Museums (3)
    • Banks (2)
    • Beverages (2)
    • Boating (4)
    • Clothing and Accessories (2)
    • Grocery Stores and Markets (8)
    • Home and Garden (4)
    • Laundries - Cleaners (1)
    • Pharmacies (1)
    • Restaurants (10)
    • Pet Services (1)
    • Public Schools (1)
    • Retail Shops and Markets (4)
    • Spas - Beauty (2)
    • Water Activities (1)
    • Public Schools (1)
    • Art and Museums (3)
    • Banks (2)
    • Beverages (2)
    • Boating (4)
    • Clothing and Accessories (2)
    • Grocery Stores and Markets (8)
    • Health Clubs and Spas (2)
    • Home and Garden (4)
    • Laundries - Cleaners (1)
    • Pharmacies (1)
    • Restaurants (10)
    • Pet Services (1)
    • Retail Shops and Markets (4)
    • Spas - Beauty (2)
    • Water Activities (1)

    19 Montclair Avenue

    Storybook Waterfront Shelter Island Cottage With Dock Shelter Island
    $2,000,000

    This home has been sold

    We have 2 similar homes for sale.
    See Results

    • Cape
      4 Bedrooms   2 Bathrooms
    map

    Overview

    Enjoy unrivaled sunrise and sunset views from this spectacular Shelter Island waterfront compound. An absolutely charming and unique property with waterfront on West Neck Harbor and waterviews of West Neck Creek. Beautiful and quiet Shelter Island is located conveniently to the newly discovered wine country the new Napa Valley and to all the Hamptons have to offer. Enclosed by clematis-covered white picket fence and completely renovated with every modern convenience, this 4-bedroom cottage has a spa/gym building, additional accessory building, outdoor shower, and a beautifully landscaped bluestone patio with stone firepit and millstone fountain. The first floor of the house has a spacious open layout including a living room with fireplace, dining and sitting rooms, chef's kitchen with stainless appliances, a bright and airy harborside sunroom, open creekside porch with swing plus 3 bedrooms and a full bath. The second floor living room with cathedral ceiling and skylight has a free-standing woodburning stove, large flat screen TV with surround sound, house media control center, wet bar and 2 spacious decks--each overlooking either harbor or creek. The master suite, with cathedral ceiling has a spa-bath with Jacuzzi perfectly situated for relaxing and watching the sailboats go by, huge walk-in shower and poured concrete floors. These Shelter Island grounds have old growth and specimen trees, lavender beds, a grand wisteria vine and many other flowering plants. The dock allows swimming, boating and fishing and there's a deep water mooring too! Permit is pending for inground pool.

    Agents  Ask us a question

    Peter McCracken Licensed Associate RE Broker p (631) 749-2526 m (631) 774-0107 pmccracken@corcoran.com Email Me See my 6 other sale listings
    Cee Scott Brown Licensed Associate RE Broker m (516) 383-2011 p (631) 899-0119 ceebrown@corcoran.com Email Me See my 16 other sale listings
    Jack Pearson Licensed Associate RE Broker p (631) 899-0307 m (516) 457-7111 jpearson@corcoran.com Email Me See my 15 other sale listings

    Essentials

    • Price$2,000,000
    • StyleCape
    • Bedrooms4
    • Bathrooms2
    • Stories2
    • Approx. Sq. Ft.2,053
    • Acreage.56
    • Year Built1936

    Key Features

    • Bayfront
    • Central air
    • Cul-de-sac location
    • Detached garage
    • Exercise room
    • Great room
    • Loft
    • Media room
    • Office
    • Outdoor shower
    • Cable/satellite

      All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer. Equal Housing Opportunity. The Corcoran Group is a licensed real estate broker. Owned and operated by NRT LLC.

      What would you like to know about this home?

      Close

      To:

      Thanks, your question has been sent to the agent.

      A response should be sent shortly.

      What would you like to know about this home?

      Close

      To:

      Thanks, your question has been sent to the agent.

      A response should be sent shortly.

      See all rates