Skip to main content
  • Shelter Island, NY
Enter a location, address, ZIP or property ID
Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, Enter to select
  • Shelter Island, NY
Click to select sorting

Searching for homes for rent in Shelter Island, NY

  • Shelter Island

    82 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • ranch
    • 4 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 2104 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $40,000
  • Shelter Island

    68 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • ranch
    • 3 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 2061 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $30,000
  • Shelter Island

    14 A Heron Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • beach-house
    • 3 BD
    • 4 BA
    • 2000 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $60,000
  • Shelter Island

    37 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • cottage
    • 5 BD
    • 4 BA
    • 2 HB
    • 5730 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $95,000
  • Shelter Island

    13 Winthrop Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

    • Residential
    • 1 BD
    • 1 BA
    • 692 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $13,500
  • Shelter Island

    60 South Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • contemporary
    • 4 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 2974 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $28,000