Skip to main content
WEB ID: 104921

55 North Cartwright Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

sold | single-family

4 beds
1.5 baths/1 half bath
1750 Approx. Sqft/ 3.4 acres

    This is a carousel. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate. Click on image or "Expand" button to open the fullscreen carousel.

    The Details

    About 55 North Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Historic Turn-of-the Century Shelter Island Farmhouse

    Quintessential 1890 Shelter Island 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath farmhouse near Coecles Harbor Marina enjoys all of the charm that made past summers so wonderfully memorable. A tree lined winding drive leads to the top of a hill where beautiful expansive lawns surround this charming vintage farmhouse. The master suite on the second floor has a bathing room and there are also 3 other bedrooms and bath on this level. The main...

    key features

  • Breakfast area
  • Finished basement
  • Listing agent

    Interested? Let’s talk.

    How should we connect with you?
    How should we connect with you?

    Shelter Island

    Though there are roads on Shelter Island, you cannot drive to it. Instead, access is only made possible via ferry, either from Greenport in the north or North Haven in the south. That restriction makes Shelter Island an enchanting locale, floating idyllically between and blending the lifestyles of the twin forks of Long Island. Mashomack Preserve takes up an entire third of Shelter Island—thousands of acres of protected nature highlighted by flourishing plant and animal life. However, it’s not all ducks and turtles here; in the land that remains, human life flourishes as well. Demand in Shelter Island is exceptionally high, something homes in the area rise to match. Charming and glorious, these timeless residences vary in style and size—from waterfront estates to hillside Victorians to rustic farmhouses. Island life also means abundant water, something Shelter Island takes advantage of at its serene beaches and bustling marinas.

    Building Sales History

    Sales History for 55 North Cartwright Rd

    datepricelisting status
    07/01/2020$1,123,000Sold (asking: $1,123,000)

    Monthly Costs

    Mortgage Calculator

    • 30 Years Fixed
    • 20 Years Fixed
    • 15 Years Fixed
    • 7 Years Fixed
    • 5 Years Fixed

    Not sure if this fits your budget? There might be tax savings, so talk to an agent for details.

    • Principal & Interest$5,101.02
    • Property Taxes0
    • Maintenance / Common Charges0
    These values are approximated. For any further information, please .
    All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer. Images may be digitally enhanced photos, virtually staged photos, artists' renderings of future conditions, or otherwise modified, and therefore may not necessarily reflect actual site conditions. Accordingly, interested parties must confirm actual site conditions for themselves, in person.