Skip to main content
  • Shelter Island, NY
Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, Enter to select
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • Sort By
    • Newest
    • Price low to high
    • Price high to low
    • Most square feet
    • Open houses
    • Coming Soon

We're looking for your new home...

  • New listing
    Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 41 Manhanset Road | 5 Beds, 6 Baths
    Shelter Island

    41 Manhanset Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • single-family
    • 5 BD
    • 6 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 7,500 SQ. FT
    • VIRTUAL TOUR
    COURTESY OF CORCORAN
    $5,950,000
  • New listing
    Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 28 South Midway Road | 4 Beds, 2 Baths
    Shelter Island

    28 South Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • single-family
    • 4 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 2,286 SQ. FT
      COURTESY OF CORCORAN
      $2,350,000
    • New listing
      Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 14c North Cartwright Road
      Shelter Island

      14c North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      • land
        COURTESY OF CORCORAN
        $850,000
      • New listing
        Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 7 Gazon Road | 3 Beds, 2 Baths
        Shelter Island

        7 Gazon Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

        • single-family
        • 3 BD
        • 2 BA
        • 1 HB
        • 1,900 SQ. FT
          COURTESY OF CORCORAN
          $3,400,000
        • New listing
          Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 53 West Neck Road | 3 Beds, 2 Baths
          Shelter Island

          53 West Neck Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

          • single-family
          • 3 BD
          • 2 BA
          • 1,114 SQ. FT
            COURTESY OF CORCORAN
            $2,500,000
          • New listing
            Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 15 Shorewood Road | 3 Beds, 2 Baths
            Shelter Island

            15 Shorewood Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

            • single-family
            • 3 BD
            • 2 BA
            • 1 HB
            • 2,394 SQ. FT
              COURTESY OF CORCORAN
              $1,975,000
            • New listing
              Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 82 North Cartwright Road | 3 Beds, 3 Baths
              Shelter Island

              82 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

              • single-family
              • 3 BD
              • 3 BA
              • 2,104 SQ. FT
                COURTESY OF CORCORAN
                $1,875,000
              • New listing
                Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 8 Hilo Drive
                Shelter Island

                8 Hilo Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

                • land
                  COURTESY OF CORCORAN
                  $1,200,000
                • New listing
                  Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 5 Fox Hollow Run
                  Shelter Island

                  5 Fox Hollow Run, Shelter Island, NY 11964

                  • land
                    COURTESY OF CORCORAN
                    $549,000
                  • New listing
                    Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 7 Johnston Road
                    Shelter Island

                    7 Johnston Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

                    • land
                      COURTESY OF CORCORAN
                      $475,000