Skip to main content
  • Shelter Island, NY
Enter a location, address, ZIP or property ID
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • Sort By
    • Recommended
    • Newest
    • Price low to high
    • Price high to low
    • Most square feet
    • Open houses
    • Coming Soon

Searching for homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY

  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island Heights | View 13 Spring Garden Avenue | 3 Beds, 2 Baths
    Shelter Island Heights

    13 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

    • victorian
    • 3 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 2,292 SQ. FT
    • On-Site Open House
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $2,700,000
  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 7 Gazon Road | 3 Beds, 2 Baths
    Shelter Island

    7 Gazon Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • cape
    • 3 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 1,900 SQ. FT
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $3,250,000
  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 1 Lake Drive
    Shelter Island

    1 Lake Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • Land
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $435,000
  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 41 Manhanset Road | 5 Beds, 6 Baths
    Shelter Island

    41 Manhanset Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • traditional
    • 5 BD
    • 6 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 7,500 SQ. FT
    • Virtual Tour
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $5,950,000
  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island Heights | View 10 Serpentine Drive | 3 Beds, 3 Baths
    Shelter Island Heights

    10 Serpentine Drive, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

    • contemporary
    • 3 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 1,739 SQ. FT
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $3,500,000
  • Homes for sale in Shelter Island | View 11 Peconic Avenue | 3 Beds, 1 Bath
    Shelter Island

    11 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • ranch
    • 3 BD
    • 1 BA
    • 1,178 SQ. FT
    Corcoran logo
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,495,000